So Tiffany went to the wrecking yard to checkout another e36 for the part. It didn't want to be removed or couldn't be. So far the speculation is its part of the dash. Even though I found a pic of a dash with out it but it may be part of something that needed more work to get it out. So after work it's off to the dealership to ask some questions and maybe goodguys to ask James some questions. And maybe even a couple calls to insurance and the shop to say shit still isn't fixed right and the wrong part was ordered.